So, I’ve been getting a lot of asks over the last few months asking why I strongly dislike TFIOS by John Green as much as I do. And for the most part, all the recent askers have been surprisingly polite, considering the more aggressive ones I’ve received in the past on the subject. Anyway, I’ve answered a bunch of them separately, but I’ve decided to condense all of my theories, opinions and arguments into one succinct post.
Now, I'll be blunt about my feelings on the book by copying and pasting my response to a recent ask upon the nature of my dislike. “The story is incredibly formulaic and unrealistic,